Arrowhead Lake is best known for its quiet roads, wooded lots, beaches, and laid-back lake atmosphere—but residents and weekend visitors also know that some of the area’s best meals are waiting just beyond the gates. The neighborhood itself is primarily residential, so the local food scene gathers along nearby PA-940, Locust Ridge Road, and the commercial pockets toward Blakeslee, Pocono Pines, and Pocono Lake.
Whether you need a quick breakfast before a day on the water, pizza for a family gathering, or a relaxed dinner after hiking, Arrowhead Lake gives you plenty of options within a short drive.
Start Close to Home: Pinewood Deli
The most convenient food stop for Arrowhead Lake is Pinewood Deli at 2359 Locust Ridge Road, just outside the community. It is the kind of practical neighborhood spot that becomes essential during a long weekend: breakfast sandwiches, cold cuts, prepared foods, snacks, drinks, and easy takeout for the lake house.
- Cuisine: Deli, sandwiches, breakfast, grab-and-go foods
- Price range: $–$$
- Best for: Picnic supplies, casual lunches, and stocking the refrigerator
- Why it stands out: Its location near Arrowhead Lake makes it one of the easiest places to pick up food without committing to a full restaurant meal.
Pinewood is especially useful when your group has different schedules. Grab a sandwich before heading to the beach, pick up sides for a backyard cookout, or stop in for essentials you forgot at the grocery store.
Breakfast Favorite: Moyer’s Country Kitchen
For a classic Pocono breakfast, make the short drive to Moyer’s Country Kitchen on PA-940. This is a hearty, old-fashioned breakfast-and-lunch destination where the portions are generous and the menu leans comfortably traditional.
The signature order is the German pancake, often served with fruit or sweet toppings. Eggs Benedict, country-style breakfasts, kielbasa, scrapple, sausage, cheesesteaks, and fried fish also appear among customer favorites. Moyer’s is the sort of place where coffee keeps coming and nobody minds if you arrive in hiking clothes.
- Cuisine: American diner and country cooking
- Price range: $–$$
- Best for: Breakfast, brunch, and filling midday meals
- Why it stands out: Big portions, familiar comfort food, and a genuinely local atmosphere.
Go early on busy summer mornings, especially on holiday weekends. Moyer’s is popular with families, vacationers, and locals who know that a full breakfast is the best way to start a day in the mountains.
Pizza Night at Dominic’s
When everyone wants something easy, Dominic’s Pizza at 584 PA-940 is a reliable Arrowhead-area choice. The menu goes beyond basic slices, with pizza, calzones, chicken parmigiana, wings, tenders, garlic knots, onion rings, fries, and other casual favorites.
- Cuisine: Pizza, Italian-American, subs, wings
- Price range: $
- Best for: Takeout, family dinners, game nights, and feeding a crowd
- Why it stands out: A broad comfort-food menu makes it easy to satisfy both picky children and hungry adults.
Order a classic pepperoni pie for the lake house, or mix things up with a white pizza, chicken parm, buffalo wings, and garlic knots. Dominic’s is also a good backup when rain cancels outdoor plans and everyone suddenly needs dinner.
A Casual Lunch at Stacked Deli
Stacked Deli, located at 892 PA-940, is another standout for sandwiches and wraps. It is a strong choice when you want something fresher and more customizable than standard fast food.
Popular options include turkey-and-ham sandwiches, tuna salad, buffalo chicken wraps, veggie wraps, and substantial deli-style combinations. Sides such as macaroni salad help complete the classic lunch-counter experience.
- Cuisine: Deli sandwiches, wraps, salads, American lunch fare
- Price range: $
- Best for: Quick lunches, takeout, and casual meals
- Why it stands out: Good portions, broad sandwich choices, and an easygoing neighborhood feel.
The stretch of PA-940 around Pinewood Deli, Stacked Deli, Dominic’s, and the other nearby businesses is the main everyday food corridor for Arrowhead Lake residents.
Something Sweet: My Grandma Baked a Cookie
For a bakery stop, look for My Grandma Baked a Cookie near 906 PA-940. This small bakery-and-coffee-shop concept is a natural fit for the Pocono weekend rhythm: coffee in the morning, something sweet for the drive, or dessert to bring back to the cabin.
- Cuisine: Bakery, cookies, pastries, coffee
- Price range: $–$$
- Best for: Breakfast treats, desserts, and edible gifts
- Why it stands out: A homespun bakery atmosphere and the kind of sweets that feel made for sharing around a fire pit.
Availability can vary by day and season, so calling ahead is smart if you are planning a special dessert order.
Relaxed Dinner at Murph’s Hideaway
For a more complete evening out, Murph’s Hideaway at 710 PA-940 offers a relaxed bar-and-grill setting with indoor and outdoor seating. Its menu includes ribs, steaks, fish, wings, French dip sandwiches, Reubens, clams, macaroni and cheese, and French onion soup.
- Cuisine: American tavern food, seafood, steaks, sandwiches
- Price range: $$–$$$
- Best for: Dinner, drinks, live-music evenings, and casual celebrations
- Why it stands out: It combines a broad menu with a social atmosphere that feels especially welcoming after a day outdoors.
Murph’s is a good choice when your group wants to sit down, order a round, and linger. The setting is more energetic than a deli or pizza shop without becoming overly formal.
A Special Dinner at Jubilee
For a slightly more polished meal, head east on PA-940 to Jubilee Restaurant in Pocono Pines. Located at 2067 PA-940, Jubilee is a longtime dining destination in the broader Pocono Lake area and works well for date nights, family celebrations, or dinner with visiting guests.
- Cuisine: American and regional restaurant fare
- Price range: $$–$$$
- Best for: Dinner, cocktails, celebrations, and a more traditional restaurant experience
- Why it stands out: A fuller-service setting and a menu suited to diners who want something beyond quick takeout.
The drive from Arrowhead Lake is still easy, but the atmosphere feels like a deliberate night out rather than a last-minute meal.
Local Traditions: Lake-House Feasts and Seasonal Stops
The Arrowhead Lake food tradition is less about one signature dish and more about how people eat here. Summer means grilled burgers, hot dogs, corn, watermelon, and picnic food near the lake. Autumn brings chili, apple desserts, cider, and hearty takeout after leaf-peeping or hiking. Winter weekends call for pizza, wings, soup, and comfort food shared around a fireplace.
Food trucks may also appear at seasonal events, community gatherings, breweries, markets, and festivals in the wider Pocono Lake area. Because schedules change, check event listings and local social-media pages before planning a meal around a truck.
Your Arrowhead Lake Food Strategy
For the easiest local food crawl, start near the Arrowhead entrance and Locust Ridge Road with Pinewood Deli, then follow PA-940 toward Stacked Deli and Dominic’s Pizza. Continue toward Murph’s Hideaway for dinner, or head east to Jubilee for a more traditional restaurant experience.
Arrowhead Lake may not have a dense restaurant district inside the community, but that is part of its charm. The best meals are scattered along familiar mountain roads, often in unassuming storefronts where portions are generous, service is friendly, and the food feels connected to the rhythm of Pocono life.